PAYMENTS & CLAIMS

This is a list of the insurance companies that we represent and their contact information. Affording you the ability to make payments and/or report claims directly with your current carrier outside of our normal business hours. Always report all losses to our agency even if reported direct to company so that we may file the appropriate forms with the BMV. (This does not include glass or emergency roadside claims)

Grange Mutual

Payment Mailing Address P.O. Box 740604 Cincinnati OH 45274-0604 Payments: (866)550-9222 Claims: (800)445-3030 Website: To Make Payments Website: To File Claims
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

Hagerty

Payment Mailing Address P.O. Box 1303 Traverse City MI 49685-1303 Payments: (877) 922-9701 Claims: (800)385-0274 Website: Make a Payment Website: Make a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

Indiana Farmers

Payment Mailing Address P.O. Box 856 Indianapolis IN 46206 Payments: (800)477-1660 Claims: (800)477-1660 Website: To Make a Payment Website: To File a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

Madison Mutual

Payment Mailing Address 222 E. Park St., Ste. 200 Edwardsville IL 62025 Payments: (800)766-6642 Claims: (800)766-6642 Website: Make a Payment Website: Make a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

Nationwide

Payment Mailing Address PO Box 742522 Cincinnati OH 45274-2522 Payments: (888)891-0267 Claims: (800)421-3535 Website: Make a Payment Website: Make a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

Progressive

Payment Mailing Address PO Box 894107 Los Angeles CA 90189-4107 Payments: (800)776-4737 Claims: (800)776-4737 Website: Make a Payment Website: Report a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.

State Auto

Payments: (800)288-4425 Claims: (877)722-5246 Website: Make a Payment Website: Make a Claim
Categories: Company
Updated 2 months ago.